cnma

[Back to list of manuscript types]

Manuscript Type: Correspondence

Please only use the form below if you have been explicitly asked by the editorial office not to use Editorial Manager (for example, because a decision was already made) or if Editorial Manager is unavailable.

Reviewer Instructions

Manuscripts that critically comment on publications in ChemNanoMat can be published as Correspondences if they make an important contribution to the scientific discussion. The Author of the publication to which the Correspondence pertains will have the opportunity to reply. Please formulate the comments for the Authors in a polite form, even when heavy criticism is being delivered.

To help us assess the paper we request that you answer the following questions:

  1. Please indicate if the paper makes an important contribution to the scientific discussion
  2. Please rate the length of the manuscript
  3. Please rate the verification of hypotheses and conclusions by the presented data
  4. Please indicate whether you have included attachments

    If you have information that is relevant to the comments and recommendation you have made, this can be sent either as an attachment for the Handling Editor or for the Author. Where the attachment is for the Author, please ensure that any formulations or file information will not give away your identity.

Review Form

Referee e-mail
Manuscript number

1. Please indicate if the paper makes an important contribution to the scientific discussion [help]

Question 1

2. Please rate the length of the manuscript [help]

Question 2

  • Concise and correct length
  • Too long; contains unnecessary information
  • Too short; requires additional information

3. Please rate the verification of hypotheses and conclusions by the presented data [help]

Question 3

  • Fully consistent and accurate
  • Minor inconsistencies or inaccuracies
  • Major inconsistencies or inaccuracies

Comments for the Authors

Attachments (for authors; 3 MB max. size):

Comments for the Editors

Attachments (editors only; 3 MB max. size):